Commentary on the Philosophy of Right, Chapter 29

Why the Hegelian Triad Is Not Sufficient

Hegelian ethical life is conceptually complete—family, civil society, state—and yet its application reveals something Hegel himself did not work out: ethical life appears historically in qualitatively different constitutions, and the difference between these constitutions is not already captured by the triad of family/society/state.

This is no objection to Hegel but a consequence of his own method, once that method is understood heuristically: whoever takes logic not as derivation but as an ordering achievement must expect that concrete application will introduce differentiations not yet worked out in the movement of the concept.