Presupposing

Hegel (core methodological concept)

Presupposing is positing as already-there. What is presupposed appears as found (not made). But: the presupposed is itself posited -- by the concept, which develops.

Origin

Hypothesis (Greek hypo-thesis, under-setting) as presupposition. Descartes: methodical doubt eliminates presuppositions. Kant: critique examines the conditions of possibility (presuppositions). Hegel: presupposition is sublated, not simply eliminated.

In Hegel

Enz. §1 (Remark); Science of Logic, Vol. 2, Essence

Wesenslogischer aspekt (kap. 5.5)

In the logic of essence, "presupposing" is the basic operation of external reflection. Thought relates to something that it treats as already given -- it "presupposes" it, as if it had been there before thought began. The presupposed appears as mediated -- it comes from elsewhere.

Das paradox und seine auflösung

Whoever presupposes something thereby posits it -- but as something that is not posited. Determining reflection resolves this paradox: the presupposed is itself something posited, but something necessarily posited. What I presuppose, I have (implicitly) myself posited -- but I had to posit it thus.

Hegels pointe

What we presuppose is our own product, which we have forgotten. The sublation of the presupposition: recognizing that the presupposed is posited. Then: being with oneself in the other (freedom).

Beispiel

Being appears as immediately presupposed, but is actually a result (end = beginning).

Terminologische abgrenzung

Modern usage: "to presuppose" = to assume that something holds. Hegel's usage: "to presuppose" = to treat something as being-prior-to-positing, as already-there.